Welcome to Hartley's Pizza
Hartley's Pizza, located at 432 Williams St, Cumberland, MD, is a beloved local gem known for its delicious pizza and unique wedge-shaped sandwiches. With a focus on great flavor, their pizzas feature the perfect balance of sauce and cheese, and the soft yet crispy crust ensures a delightful experience. Patrons rave about the Buffalo wings and exceptional customer service. The establishment boasts a welcoming atmosphere, where both food and staff shine brightly. Hartley's Pizza invites you to savor their distinctive offerings, encouraging guests to enjoy good times and great food, all while embracing the quirks of a cash-only policy.
-
432 Williams St, Cumberland, MD 21502, United States Hotline: +1 301-759-3095
Welcome to Hartley's Pizza, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Cumberland, Maryland, at 432 Williams St. This charming establishment serves not just pizza but offers a delightful experience that keeps locals and visitors returning for more. With a reputation built on quality ingredients and exceptional service, Hartley’s has earned its place as a beloved favorite in the community.
As you step inside, the aroma of freshly baked pizza envelops you, promising a feast that is both comforting and satisfying. Customers rave about the perfect balance of sauce and cheese on their pies, making every slice deliciously memorable. One standout dish is their turkey wedge, praised for its soft crust that’s easy to chew, providing an indulgent yet satisfying experience.
The reviews speak volumes. Troy Hartman notes that his order was ready ahead of time, a testament to the efficiency and commitment of the staff. KenandDee Becker emphasizes Hartley’s as their go-to pizza place, especially for its unique wedged pizzas and flavorful Buffalo wings. Customers like Benjamin Lee highlight the integrity and kindness of the staff, enhancing the overall dining experience.
Perhaps most remarkably, Robert Bennett enthusiastically declares their wedgies as the best around, even comparing the staff's charm to models on a runway. Each aspect of Hartley’s, from the vibrant staff to the stunning presentation of their dishes, creates an inviting atmosphere that feels like home. It’s no wonder many – including Keith “Mike Honcho” – are pleasantly surprised by the quality of food that rivals metropolitan offerings. The crust and sauce strike the ideal delicate balance, steering clear of mass production tastes and ensuring that every bite is meaningful.
For those who appreciate a robust flavor profile, Michael Evan’s additions of extra meat to his wedgies reflect the customizability that Hartley’s embraces. Whether you’re a pizza enthusiast or a casual diner, Hartley’s has something to tempt your palate, and the veggies and wings come highly recommended by Sha-Ron McQueen, who returns every visit from Georgia just to indulge.
While the restaurant operates on a cash-only basis – a minor inconvenience highlighted by the community – it’s a small price to pay for a slice of heaven. The warmth and respect patrons receive is just as nourishing as the food itself, making Hartley’s an irreplaceable fixture in the local dining scene. For a meal that nourishes the body and uplifts the spirit, look no further than Hartley’s Pizza, where every visit is as satisfying as the last.
So why wait? Grab your cash, head over to Hartley’s Pizza, and prepare for a truly delicious dining experience that will leave you longing for your next visit!
Order was ready before time quoted, pizza is delicious with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. The turkey wedge unlike most places the crust is done but soft to chew, very delicious!
Favorite hometown pizza! Their wedge-shaped are yummy too and the Buffalo wings hit the spot. Just remember to take cash!
What a great establishment. Great food and people. I accidentally gave my delivery driver a 100 dollars extra. And the next day he was at my door to return it. Not to many people left in the world that would do such a good deed. Thank you.
Their wedgies are better than any I've received from any bully. I'd let Hartley's give me wedgies all day. Every employee belongs on America's next top model and their food is just as beautiful. Recommend 10 out of 10. I love you Hartley's! Thanks for filling my mouth with flavor Papa John's could only dream of.
Pizza and Wedgies are amazing. I add extra meet to wedgies.
Only place I know of where a wedgie is a good thing... and quite tasty
Love the veggies. Came from Georgia and every time I visit the area I like to get one Staff is awesome here
A favorite local pizza restaurant. I lived in the area for several years bemoaning how it was impossible to find a local pizza place with something that made it worth going back. I had heard of Hartley's but dismissed them figuring it was another place where people who didn't know what good pizza was supposed to taste like would go. I finally broke down and ordered one day after looking at local pizza shops, and wanting anything that wasn't a national chains weak offering. It was ready in a very short time which made me slightly nervous but when I got home all of the skepticism was immediately squashed with the first bite. I couldn't believe what I was tasting and proceeded to eat about 1/2 of that XL pizza. Everything tasted right and unique. Nothing tasted like it was mass produced and the crust and sauce were very impressive. I had given up and accepted the fact that aside from going to a major metropolitan area and rolling the dice. Qr returning back to the mostly Italian city I spent my first 23ish years in that pizza would simply be something to eat but not to enjoy. Having come from a place where you could go to literally at minimum a dozen different places and get a pizza that was nothing short of amazing I thought that was the norm. Cumberland taught me how good we had it back home, but Hartley's was the restaurant that redeemed Cumberland as far as for pizza in my mind. Aside from the food the staff has always been super friendly and helpful. I've always been treated with respect and been made to feel valued as a customer. If I had any criticism it would be that I still get turned around going there but that is not their fault. The other caveat is they don't take credit cards and even though I know that, I still find myself getting there to turn around and run through an ATM. As good as the pizza is though that's a minor inconvenience and has no impact on my thoughts about Hartley's - one of the easiest 5 star reviews to write.