Hartley's Pizza Menu (Update 2025)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to Hartley's Pizza, a beloved gem located at 432 Williams St, Cumberland, MD. Offering a delightful mix of pizzas and unique wedgies, Hartley's stands out with its remarkable flavors and friendly service. Diners rave about the perfectly balanced sauce and cheese, making each pizza a must-try. Customers particularly enjoy the wedge-shaped pizzas, often remarking on the soft, yet perfectly baked crust that sets Hartley’s apart from the competition.

  • Buffalo Wings: Another crowd-pleaser, consistently highlighted by patrons.
  • Vegetable Options: Fresh and flavorsome, perfect for the veggie lovers!
  • Community Spirit: The staff’s genuine care and dedication to service create a welcoming atmosphere.

Whether you're a local or just passing through, Hartley's Pizza is an unmissable culinary experience that truly redeems the local pizza landscape.